15 Best Year For Toyota Tacoma & 3 Years To Avoid

Dan Ross

By Dan Ross

Last updated:

Since its debut in 1995, Toyota Tacoma has taken the world by storm thanks to its exceptional reliability and capability. These pick-up trucks can accompany you on both on-road and off-road adventures while carrying heavy loads. However, not all model years live up to that well-established reputation. Continue reading to discover the most reliable Toyota Tacoma years!

15 Best Tacoma Years To Buy

Toyota Tacoma has made a name for itself as one of the most trustworthy pick-up trucks, especially the first generation (from 1995 to 2004), 2013 – 2015, 2020, and 2021 model years. These compact trucks can withstand the test of time and only exhibit minor issues during their lifespan.

1995 – 2004 Toyota Tacoma

The first generation (1995 – 2004) marks the beginning of the Toyota Tacoma’s golden era. All models from this generation received exceptional ratings from buyers regarding reliability.

Only a few complaints were reported, most of which revolved around minor failures. And problems didn’t appear until the 100,000-mile mark. Some drivers in our survey shared that some defects reared their ugly heads past 50,000 miles, but they only cost around $500.

The two most beloved models are the 1996 and 2003 Tacomas. One of our test team owned a ‘96 Tacoma, which has racked up 340,000 miles by now. He usually hauls a 10,000-pound trailer, and the truck pumps out tons of torque. The only issue stemmed from the radiator, which required a replacement at 310,000 miles.

1996 Toyota Tacoma
1996 Toyota Tacoma

According to CarComplaints, there was solely one complaint about the 1996 model, which was related to the notorious rust problem. That said, that driver only noticed corrosion on the chassis after 17 years of buying. Toyota has invested tons of effort in inspecting and fixing affected vehicles for over 15 years. Until now, rust has no longer been a major issue in these models.

Another less problematic model year is the 2003 Tacoma. We tested a used 2003 mode with 197,000 miles on its odometer. The acceleration felt responsive and smooth with a lot of power, and the handling on gravel roads was stable without noticeable noise. When we towed a 5000-pound camper, the truck didn’t sacrifice much traction or steering response. This 2003 model is still a worthy investment!

2013 – 2015 Toyota Tacoma

The 2013 to 2015 models in the second generation are the best used Toyota Tacoma years. Regarding reliability scores on J.D. Power, the 2013 Tacoma gains an 86, while the 2015 gets an 85 out of 100. Toyota only carried on 4 recalls related to these model years, cementing their reputation for reliability. The best part is that their average maintenance cost is only $479 each year (according to RepairPal).

2013 Toyota Tacoma
2013 Toyota Tacoma

The 2014 year doesn’t fall short of its siblings, either. The Japanese automaker has spent nearly a decade researching and fine-tuning these pick-up trucks; no wonder the late model years steal the spotlight! The number of complaints about the 2014 Tacoma is much fewer than in previous years. Most of them are related to minor issues like failed radio and premature interior wear.

We hopped on an old 2014 Tacoma with 47,500 miles on it and had smooth cruises, both on highways and off-road. We felt a bit weighed down when hauling a 3,500 trailer, but the handling and steering were still sharp and on point. We would give it a 10 out of 10 if Toyota could make the passenger seat legroom a bit roomier, though.

2020 Toyota Tacoma

If you are eyeing recent models, the 2020 Tacoma won’t let you down. The truck received only fewer than 60 complaints, along with a single recall registered by the NHTSA. This model is also packed with innovative technological advancements, safety features, and latest powertrain options. 

2020 Toyota Tacoma
2020 Toyota Tacoma

The 3.5L 2GR-FKS V6 engine version can generate a whopping 278 HP, catering to a variety of traveling and loading purposes. Drivers also enjoy the Apple CarPlay and Android Auto for more convenience. Even better, Toyota equips this model with a Safety Sense P suite, featuring automatic emergency braking and adaptive cruise control to optimize safety.

We tested a 3.5L V6 2020 Tacoma, and the steering and handling felt responsive without major issues. The gear shift smoothly and predictably, even when we traversed serious terrain. The truck crawled over low rocks effortlessly, and the brakes were precise without taking long braking distances. However, the towing capacity might slightly lag behind other models, and we found it a bit challenging to fold the rear seats to free up more cargo space.

2021 Toyota Tacoma

According to J.D. Power, the 2021 Toyota Tacoma ranked first as the best midsize pickup in 2021, with an 83/100 overall rating and an 87/100 quality and reliability score. Being around for more than 3 years, this model has no reported recalls until now. 

2021 Toyota Tacoma
2021 Toyota Tacoma

Like its 2020 brother, this model year inherits a wealth of industry-leading safety features, giving drivers peace of mind. Besides, the available Blind-Spot Monitor informs you of vehicles in blind spots, while the Rear Cross-Traffic Alert keeps collisions at bay when backing up in parking lots or driveways.

We give our thumbs up for its off-road capability. Even without monster tires, this midsize truck navigated off-road terrain like a champ during our test drive. Its tire set turned out to be a blessing in disguise, as it minimized road noise, ensured comfort, and amplified the steering feel when we ventured off-road. 

Again, it would be better if the rear legroom and headroom were more spacious. Additionally, the tall step-up height might be a pet peeve for some drivers.

3 Toyota Tacoma Years To Avoid

2005 Toyota Tacoma

The 2005 Tacoma holds a unique place in Tacoma’s history as the first model of the second generation. With its redesigned frame, updated interior, and engine choices, Toyota aimed to elevate the Tacoma experience. 

2005 Toyota Tacoma
2005 Toyota Tacoma

However, during our testing, we quickly noticed that 2005 Tacomas are highly susceptible to frame rust, a flaw reported frequently by owners and one that we experienced firsthand. Even low-mileage models we examined showed significant frame corrosion, particularly in regions with harsh winters or high humidity. The rust issues were so prevalent that Toyota eventually issued a recall to address frame corrosion on several model years, including 2005.

Unfortunately, rust isn’t the only problem with this model year. Many 2005 Tacoma owners (and our team noticed this too) experience problems with the suspension and steering systems. During our tests, the trucks felt less stable on rough terrain, and the handling was noticeably loose. 

This was likely due to corrosion-related wear on suspension components, which also led to issues with the leaf springs cracking. Overall, we found the 2005 Tacoma to be a challenging year for Toyota, as the model fell short in durability.

2009 Toyota Tacoma

The 2009 Tacoma, another model from the second generation, came with both the 2.7L I4 and the 4.0L V6 engines, both of which have been reliable in general but showed noticeable issues in this model year. 

2009 Toyota Tacoma
2009 Toyota Tacoma

During our test drive, we observed inconsistent engine performance, including irregular idling and a tendency to stall under certain conditions. The engine problems appeared to be most prevalent in the V6 variant, where rough idling was frequently reported among users, and our own test vehicle showed similar behavior.

Another significant problem we experienced with the 2009 Tacoma was the drivetrain. On multiple occasions, we encountered issues with the drivetrain’s durability, including excessive vibrations at higher speeds. In particular, one of our test trucks developed problems with the rear differential, a common issue for the 2009 model year. 

Owners have often reported a clunking noise in the rear during gear shifts, and we also heard this in our tests. These drivetrain problems, while not safety-threatening, significantly impact the driving experience and can be costly to repair.

2016 Toyota Tacoma

The 2016 Tacoma marked the beginning of the third generation, introducing advanced technology and a redesigned interior. On paper, the upgrades seemed promising, but our tests revealed some serious flaws that make this model year one to avoid. One of the most alarming issues we encountered was with the transmission. 

2016 Toyota Tacoma
2016 Toyota Tacoma

We noticed the transmission shift harshly between gears, especially at lower speeds, causing noticeable jerking. This wasn’t just an annoyance; it compromised the truck’s reliability and smoothness on the road. Many Tacoma owners from this year report similar issues with the automatic transmission, with some even needing replacements just a few years into ownership.

The 2016 model also exhibited engine stalls, which we personally experienced when test-driving on inclines and rugged trails. We noticed the engine would occasionally lag, particularly when shifting from a stop. Additionally, this model year saw issues with the electrical system, including dashboard displays flickering unexpectedly. 

These issues were consistent with feedback from many 2016 Tacoma owners who reported intermittent failures in the electronic components, including the navigation and infotainment systems.

Some Common Toyota Tacoma Reliability Problems

Here are some common issues to keep in mind

  • Frame corrosion: Particularly prevalent in 2005-2008 models, frame rust has been a costly and frequent issue. Excessive rust often requires frame replacements, especially for vehicles used in regions with harsh winters or high humidity.
  • Transmission malfunctions: The 2016 and 2017 Tacomas have ongoing transmission issues, including rough shifting, slipping, and frequent gear changes. These issues can lead to uncomfortable driving experiences and sometimes costly repairs.
  • Engine stalls and misfires: Models from 2006 to 2012 often experience engine stalling, misfires, and oil leaks. These problems not only affect performance but also raise concerns about long-term engine reliability.
  • Suspension wear and steering: Many Tacomas from the 2005-2009 period have reported suspension issues, such as worn leaf springs and a loose steering wheel. These issues can lead to bumpy rides and may affect handling.
  • Paint peeling and fading: A cosmetic but recurring problem, especially in 2006-2008 Tacomas. Premature peeling and cracking paint often necessitate expensive repairs to maintain the vehicle’s appearance.

Conclusion

The Toyota Tacoma has a reputation for durability and off-road capability, but certain years stand out as either exceptional or problematic. For those seeking the best, the above models are among the top recommendations, offering a strong balance of reliability, fewer major repairs, and solid resale value. Remember to steer clear of the 2005, 2009, and 2016 models!

Dan Ross

Dan Ross

Dan Ross is an Automotive Engineer and blogger, He has experience in vehicle systems design, performance testing, and project management. With a passion for automotive excellence, he ensures high standards in design and safety. Through Intersection Magazine, Dan educates and connects with enthusiasts and professionals alike, sharing industry insights and updates.

Leave a Comment